It's been a while, so let's get back into it. Hitters. Lots of them. 'Nuff said.
Infielders
Dan Shaute
Victor Nolt
John Hernandez
Steve Womack
Icehouse Barna
Greg Carson
Dick Donahue
Fenton Bevens
Outfielders & Catchers
Paul Gomes
George Johnson
Ed Rodgers
Ralph Spencer
Ron Mihalic
Thanks in advance to all participants.
Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
Moderators: CrazedCougars, The_Old_Bear
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
Everyone except for Donahue.
-
- Posts: 172
- Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2017 9:53 am
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
All but Nolt, Donahue, Spencer and Mihalic for me
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
All but Nolt, Carson, Donahue and Mihalic.
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
I'm going to vote for about half these codebits, though most of them hit their career totals more through longevity than talent. The average SimD career length is about 16 years and these players mostly went 18-20 years and beyond. I also note a dearth of Detroit and Oakland and Pittsburgh nominees this time around. Curious. Were those teams having down years? Ah, well. No matter.
1b Dan Shaute, Minnesota
Only one of two I pick with a BA of .300 of more.
SS Steve Womack, Minnesota
The only one of the nominess who - I felt - was head and shoulders above the rest.
CF Paul Gomes, Brooklyn
Fell off the face of the earth once he hit his second decline year, but was royalty prior to that.
RF George Johnson, Minnesota
Was a quality player right into his twilight years.
1b Dan Shaute, Minnesota
Only one of two I pick with a BA of .300 of more.
SS Steve Womack, Minnesota
The only one of the nominess who - I felt - was head and shoulders above the rest.
CF Paul Gomes, Brooklyn
Fell off the face of the earth once he hit his second decline year, but was royalty prior to that.
RF George Johnson, Minnesota
Was a quality player right into his twilight years.
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
My votes are for:
Shaute
Hernandez
Womack
Barna
Bevens
Gomes
Johnson
Rodgers
Shaute
Hernandez
Womack
Barna
Bevens
Gomes
Johnson
Rodgers
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2200-2204): Hitters
I am pleased to announce that the following players have been inducted into the Hall of Fame (4/6 votes were necessary):
Dan Shaute
John Hernandez
Steve Womack
Icehouse Barna
Fenton Bevens
Paul Gomes
George Johnson
Ed Rodgers
For the first time, however, we had a few split votes. The following players received 3 votes, so because it was an even 50-50, if there is anyone who would like to change their vote they may do so on this thread. If there is no change, the players will not be inducted.
Greg Carson
Ralph Spencer
Thanks to everyone for voting extremely quickly, the next ballot should be out soon.
Dan Shaute
John Hernandez
Steve Womack
Icehouse Barna
Fenton Bevens
Paul Gomes
George Johnson
Ed Rodgers
For the first time, however, we had a few split votes. The following players received 3 votes, so because it was an even 50-50, if there is anyone who would like to change their vote they may do so on this thread. If there is no change, the players will not be inducted.
Greg Carson
Ralph Spencer
Thanks to everyone for voting extremely quickly, the next ballot should be out soon.