Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Discussions for the Jesse Orosco League.

Moderator: klobas2

Post Reply
klobas2
Posts: 460
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 11:09 am

Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by klobas2 »

All,

We haven't had a HOF vote in more than 20 seasons. That's on me. Life gets in the way.

Below is the list of potential candidates I've found by looking through past all-star votes. I'm sure I've missed some very worthy candidates. Please bring them up below if we've missed any.

I tried to keep this pretty exclusive given that we have a whole generation of players to vote on. It may be more productive to list the players we think aren't worthy.

The ballot:

Allen, Howard - 4x AS - 2x CY - 237 wins, 3395 Ks, 3.61 ERA
Alou, Ed - 10x AS - 6x CY, ROY - 282 wins, 2919 Ks, 2.91 ERA
Brady, Mel - 7x AS - 4x CY - 234 wins, 2656 Ks, 3.63 ERA
Chouinard, Jesse - 8x AS - 2x CY - 253 wins, 2584 Ks, 3.34 ERA
Crockett, Barry - 10x AS - 1x MVP - 3030 hits, 528 HR, .900 OPS, 1x Batting Champ
Cummings, Jorge - 14x AS - 1x MVP, 9x GG, ROY - 3045 hits, 579 HR (#6 All-Time), 2023 RBI (#2 All-Time) .830 OPS
Deal, Tommy - 9x AS - 1x CY - 271 wins, 3211 Ks, 3.34 ERA
Dumbledore, Xavier - 8x AS - 1x MVP, 2x GG - 2716 hits, 454 HR, .820 OPS, 4x 30/30 seasons
Earwicker, H.C. - 10x AS - 3x CY - 259 wins, 3339 Ks, 3.47 ERA
Gessler, Stan - 11x AS - 1x CY - 3066 hits, 636 HR (#1 All-Time), .856 OPS
Guise, Buddy - 9x AS - ROY - 2361 hits, 447 HR, .880 OPS
Haines, Oxford - 9x AS - 3x GG - 2478 hits, 421 HR, .882 OPS, 4x 30/30 seasons
Hoch, Ad - 13x AS - 1x MVP, 3x GG - 3417 hits (#5 All-Time), 527 2B, 159 3B (#1 All-Time), 468 HR, 701 SB (#6 All-Time), .800 OPS, 8x 30/30 seasons)
Hostetler, Gary - 11x AS - 1x MVP, ROY - 3206 hits, 496 HR, .786 OPS, 4x 30/30 seasons
Hunt, Milt - 16x AS - 3x MVP, 3x GG - 3777 hits (#2 All-Time), 648 2B (#2 All-Time), 582 HR (#5 All-Time), 354 SB, .915 OPS, 2x Batting Champ, 2x 30/30 seasons
Johnson, Alan - 9x AS - 1x CY, 2x FOY - 240 wins, 2898 Ks, 3.53 ERA
Johnson, Jangle George - 8x AS - 3x CY - 209 wins, 2726 Ks, 3.67 ERA
Johnston, Joe - 9x AS - 1x CY - 284 wins, 3649 Ks (#3 All-Time), 3.65 ERA
Linz, Salty - 5x AS - 2x CY - 236 wins, 3079 Ks, 3.87 ERA
Macey, Two Face - 14x AS - 2x MVP, 1x GG - 2663 hits, 436 HR, .881 OPS, 2x Batting Champ
Mitchell, Trevor - 6x AS - 3x GG - 2189 hits, 403 HR, .899 OPS, 3x 30/30 Seasons)
Perzanowski, Mike - 5x AS - 2x CY, 1x GG - 248 wins, 2699 Ks, 3.26 ERA
Rice, Wedo - 8x AS - 3x MVP, 4x GG - 2818 hits, 471 HR, 498 SB, .855 OPS, 2x Batting Champ, 2x 30/30 seasons
Rosenfeld, Glenn - 10x AS - 3x FOY - 474 saves, 1.38 WHIP, 3.55 ERA
Snozzcumber, Irwin - 11x AS - 1x MVP - 3167 hits, 561 HR (#10 All-Time), .807 OPS, 4x 30/30 seasons
Spence, Pedro - 6x AS - 2x MVP, 3x GG - 2613 hits, 252 HR, .769 OPS
Stoops, John - 6x AS - 3x CY, 1x GG - 264 wins, 2901 Ks, 3.44 ERA
Wilson, Drew - 13x AS - 4x MVP, 4x GG - 2449 hits, 350 HR, .877 OPS, 2x Batting Champ
Yojimbo - 6x AS - 1x MVP - 1641 hits, 360 HR, .897 OPS
Last edited by klobas2 on Thu Dec 14, 2017 12:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
klobas2
Posts: 460
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 11:09 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by klobas2 »

Seattle votes for:

Ed Alou
Barry Crockett
Jorge Cummings
Tommy Deal
Xavier Dumbledore
H.C. Earwicker
Stan Gessler
Oxford Haines
Ad Hoch
Gary Hostetler
Milt Hunt
Alan Johnson
Joe Johnston
Two Face Macey
Wedo Rice
Glenn Rosenfeld
Irwin Snozzcumber
Drew Wilson
allvols
Posts: 334
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 7:20 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by allvols »

ridgerunners vote for
Ed Alou
Barry Crockett
Jorge Cummings
Tommy Deal
Xavier Dumbledore
H.C. Earwicker
Stan Gessler
Oxford Haines
Ad Hoch
Gary Hostetler
Milt Hunt
Joe Johnston
Two Face Macey
Wedo Rice
Glenn Rosenfeld
Irwin Snozzcumber
Drew Wilson
*And a write in vote from the veterans committee: http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=11058847
Ron Swanson, not only for the stats bur also his fantastic mustache.

Thanks for putting this together, really good to see some old names.
Alan Johnsen did not make my list. he's kinda the same as chouinard , perzanowski and stoops
Drew Wilson, only the 4 mvp's got him over
User avatar
bygmester
Posts: 518
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:59 am
Location: Ittoqqortoormiit, Greenland

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by bygmester »

Redlegs vote for:
Ed Alou
Mel Brady
Barry Crockett
Jorge Cummings
Tommy Deal
Xavier Dumbledore
H.C. Earwicker
Stan Gessler
Oxford Haines
Ad Hoch
Gary Hostetler
Milt Hunt
Joe Johnston
Two Face Macey
Wedo Rice
Glenn Rosenfeld
Irwin Snozzcumber
Drew Wilson
“Every strike brings me closer to the next home run.”
-George Herman "Babe" Ruth
klobas2
Posts: 460
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 11:09 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by klobas2 »

Need to amend my vote to include Mel Brady. I was underwhelmed by his raw numbers, but 4 Cy Youngs is impressive.
Vinnland
Posts: 326
Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2017 9:08 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by Vinnland »

Vinnland votes for
Mel Brady
Barry Crockett
Jorge Cummings
Tommy Deal
Xavier Dumbledore
H.C. Earwicker
Stan Gessler
Oxford Haines
Ad Hoch
Gary Hostetler
Milt Hunt
Joe Johnston
Two Face Macey
Wedo Rice
Glenn Rosenfeld
Irwin Snozzcumber
Drew Wilson
Ed Alou
sjpode
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Oct 19, 2017 4:14 pm

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by sjpode »

New kid on the block voting here. but here's my votes:

Ed Alou
Barry Crockett
H C Earwicker
Milt Hunt
Two Face Macey
Wedo Rice
Ad Hoch
Irwin Snozzcumber
Drew Wilson
Gary Hostetler

Thanks. Good job
klobas2
Posts: 460
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 11:09 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by klobas2 »

bump to top of message board. this vote will be closed in one week.
zoocorp
Posts: 147
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 5:42 am

Re: Long overdue JOL Hall of Fame Ballot

Post by zoocorp »

TY Klobas

alan Johnson
Johnston
macey
Mitchell
rice
snozzcumber
Wilson
alou
brady
crockett
cummings
dumbeldore
gessler
haines
hoch
Hostetler
hunt
Post Reply

Return to “Jesse Orosco League”