Trade advice in the Billy Hamilton League (Dynasty League)

[Angelhonandez]

I need your help with this trade offer. This is a (Dynasty League)

I have been offered:
John Ryan
Terry Olson
Lee Biggs
Gabe Small
Bart Spilman
Toshiichi Cho
2073 Draft Pick Rd 1(MIL)
2072 Draft Pick Rd 1(MIL)
2071 Draft Pick Rd 1(MIL)
2070 Draft Pick Rd 1(MIL)
2069 Draft Pick Rd 1(MIL)

I would give up:
Woody Senteney
Emil Kilhullen
Charlie Nieves


Here is a link to my depth chart

Here is a link to the other owner's depth chart

And here is a link to my league's standings

Thanks for the help,
Angelhonandez

[Angelhonandez]

starting rebuild. My only real issue is what is the real value of 5 playoff picks. The players he added are filler.

[MDorf]

No chance I'm trading those guys for just picks. I doubt there is a package where you and he will agree for all 3 together, but I am including what my counter would be at the bottom. Due to Kilhullen hitting decline this OS, you probably won't get any legit prospects for him. You should be getting a first and a good pitching prospect for Senteney, though you're probably looking at a young one. I doubt anyone is going to give up a pitcher that is close to ML ready for a 33 year old, no matter how good he is. Nieves should bring you 3 pieces, and at least 1 of those should be a top tier prospect. He has some good prospects, so it just depends on how willing he is to include them. I would probably counter with Combs, Branom, Ardell and 2 firsts for all 3. I doubt he goes for it, but the least I would take would be swapping Branom for a first. That is fair value, and there is no reason to take less at this point. If you can't get there and you are wanting to move them, I would be sending out offers for them individually for my breakdown.