Trade advice in the Speaker Wilson League (Dynasty League)

[itzaboy]

I need your help with this trade offer. This is a (Dynasty League)

I have been offered:
Vazzrick Steele
Dewey Cirillo

I would give up:
Goat Batista
Ed Gochnauer
2006 Draft Pick Rd 1(CLE)


Here is a link to my depth chart

Here is a link to the other owner's depth chart

And here is a link to my league's standings

Thanks for the help,
itzaboy

[MDorf]

It would be too much for me. A bench hitter and a decent reliever isn't going to make enough difference to pay a first and a good prospect.

[Covid18]

You're basically giving up two of the same skill guys for 2 that are 11 years older, plus a draft pick.

If you think these two players are going to take you to the next level, yes. If they are just a slight improvement, I'd say no.

Neither of your kids is anything special, but you never know what a draft pick is worth. The hitter he's offering doesn't appear to me to help you much, except depth. The pitcher may be of some help, but he's not a superstar.

I would pass, but it's a decent offer.

[Michael1]

These two should be 15 and 14 until they reach 21 and see where they are.

[Gardy101]

Steele is off to a hot start which makes him look better than he is. He's a bench player.

Cirillo is a good reliever but he's too old to be trading a prospect like Batista or a 1st.

Gochnauer is a guy who you might want to see what the other owner would give up for.