Trade advice in the Speaker Wilson League (Dynasty League)

[itzaboy]

I need your help with this trade offer. This is a (Dynasty League)

I have been offered:
Keiichiro Yoshida
Ed Krieger
2008 Draft Pick Rd 2(MIN)

I would give up:
Jim Clancy


Here is a link to my depth chart

Here is a link to the other owner's depth chart

And here is a link to my league's standings

Thanks for the help,
itzaboy

[Gardy101]

Full disclosure, I'm in this league, but I feel like you could get more for your guy.

[Hamilton2]

You have an A overall SP with 2 seasons prior to declines hitting. Likely a high end SP 1 for a season and half, then a solid, useful starter for another 3+ seasons.

In exchange you are getting ... what? A lottery ticket 2nd round pick, a #4/5 SP in his 30's, and a hitter who MIGHT be low A-/A+, but most likely stalls out at B+/A+ (low power grade) or A-/A (low end contact).

There is nothing special here for you. I think you can and should get at least 2 1st rounders or similar quality pieces. And if you can't, I don't know why you would move him at all. If it only costs a 2nd rounder, 1 veteran filler, and a MEH longshot mid 20's guy to get an A overall pitcher ... maybe you should be buying instead of selling?

[itzaboy]

You have an A overall SP with 2 seasons prior to declines hitting. Likely a high end SP 1 for a season and half, then a solid, useful starter for another 3+ seasons.

In exchange you are getting ... what? A lottery ticket 2nd round pick, a #4/5 SP in his 30's, and a hitter who MIGHT be low A-/A+, but most likely stalls out at B+/A+ (low power grade) or A-/A (low end contact).

There is nothing special here for you. I think you can and should get at least 2 1st rounders or similar quality pieces. And if you can't, I don't know why you would move him at all. If it only costs a 2nd rounder, 1 veteran filler, and a MEH longshot mid 20's guy to get an A overall pitcher ... maybe you should be buying instead of selling?

Thanks for the insight, I'll be declining this deal.