I vote yes to all.
Dwyer and Hawblitzel didn't have great career totals (besides in HRs), but were dynamic offensive players. Gingras and Swanson were just plain locks, and the 2112 runs, 150+ triples, batting titles, and 7 WS rings of Jim Davis were impossible to ignore.
Warhop and Dorsey were tougher picks. Warhop was a great defensive shortstop with HOF worthy carer totals in categories for leadoff hitters. Dorsey was a bit more dynamic offensively, and had 3 fantastic MV seasons.
HOF vote - 2057
Re: HOF vote - 2057
Voting is still open. All owners are welcome to vote, and anyone who already voted can change their vote up until the deadline.
Re: HOF vote - 2057
Swanson - Yes
Warhop - Yes
Davis - Yes
Gingras - Yes
Dwyer - No
Hawblitzel - No
Dorsey - Yes
Warhop - Yes
Davis - Yes
Gingras - Yes
Dwyer - No
Hawblitzel - No
Dorsey - Yes
Re: HOF vote - 2057
They all deserve to go in as far as I'm concerned. Yes to all.
Re: HOF vote - 2057
I'm closing the voting. We got 7 owners to vote. Thanks to Soggy, jmckeean, Kaya, Pecker, pittstirs, and jbence for their participation. All candidates were elected, with the results below:
Swanson - 7/7
Warhop - 5/7
Davis - 6/7
Gingras - 7/7
Dwyer - 5/7
Hawblitzel - 5/7
Dorsey - 6/7
Swanson - 7/7
Warhop - 5/7
Davis - 6/7
Gingras - 7/7
Dwyer - 5/7
Hawblitzel - 5/7
Dorsey - 6/7
Re: HOF vote - 2057
What is the percentage needed to get in? For some reason I thought it was 75%.