As we are very near the midpoint of the season (in fact, tonight marks 81 games played) ... the thought has been on my mind about trying to resurrect the Hall of Fame. I've requested HOF Commissioner credentials from Admin, since Damien435 has left the site and took his credentials with him.
The last players inducted into our Hall were from 1989, so I've been looking at the players who retired but appeared in All Star games over the last 37 years to find the ones who retired in '89. There are just under 500 of them. Of those 500, 15 played during 1989 and a surprising 7 of them are still alive. One is actually already in the Hall: Arson Daley.
I've also been trying to remember the guidelines we used for nomination to the Hall. In SimDynasty, we have no subjective values to measure. No clubhouse character, no newspaper interviews or sports magazines/internet stories/personality profiles to read, and no way to judge how much a player boosts or harms a team's morale with his off-the-field antics or community philanthropy. All we have are numbers, so let's be sure of the numbers.
There is an excellent sabermetric article based on the work of Bill James at: https://www.beyondtheboxscore.com/2014/ ... -standards if anyone wants to take a deep dive into the numbers but here is what I can remember of the guidelines we used for nomination to the Hall:
BATTERS
Any one of the following:
5 years as an All Star
MVP Award
3,000 Hits
500 HR
500 SB
or
Any two of the following:
ROY Award
2 or more Gold Glove Awards
2,500 Hits
300 SB
300 HR
.300 or higher career BA
.750 or higher OPS
PITCHERS
Any one of the following:
5 years as an All Star
Cy Young Award
FOY Award 3 or more consecutive years
3,000 Strikeouts
300 Wins
300 Saves
or
Any two of the following:
ROY Award
FOY Award
2 or more Gold Glove Awards
2,500 Strikeouts
250 Saves
ERA lower than 3.30
WHIP lower than 1.35
I'm probably "massaging" that memory a little but that's pretty darn close. Thoughts, anyone...?
Bringing Back the Hall of Fame
Discussions for the Goose Goslin League.
Moderator: ballmark
Re: Bringing Back the Hall of Fame
Looking at the nomination filter and the players it generates, I think the "5 years as an All Star" needs to be bumped to the "Any *two* of the following" list using that factor alone to nominate a player is creating some awfully weak candidates that probably should not be nominated.
Also, the OPS number should likely be bumped up to .800.
Still, on the whole, I'd rather more candidates were generated than fewer, and let the voters be the deciders on who gets in and who doesn't. But before people vote, they should take a look at who is already there to get a feel for the level of player Hall membership requires.
Also, the OPS number should likely be bumped up to .800.
Still, on the whole, I'd rather more candidates were generated than fewer, and let the voters be the deciders on who gets in and who doesn't. But before people vote, they should take a look at who is already there to get a feel for the level of player Hall membership requires.
Return to “Goose Goslin League”
Jump to
- News & Announcements
- Baseball Game Questions
- Football Game Questions
- Baseball Suggestions And Enhancements
- Football Suggestions And Enhancements
- Check This Out!
- Baseball League Discussions
- ↳ Dynasty Leagues
- ↳ Willie Mays League
- ↳ Carl Dunn League
- ↳ Pete Rose League
- ↳ Goose Goslin League
- ↳ Ralph Kiner League
- ↳ Tim Raines League
- ↳ Ken Griffey Jr League
- ↳ Kirby Puckett League
- ↳ Rickey Henderson League
- ↳ Simmons Davis League
- ↳ Cesar Cedeno League
- ↳ Joe Medwick League
- ↳ Speaker Wilson League
- ↳ Billy Hamilton League
- ↳ Johnny Bench League
- ↳ Larry Doby League
- ↳ Minnie Minoso League
- ↳ Ashburn Crawford League
- ↳ Joe DiMaggio League
- ↳ Max Carey League
- ↳ Vada Pinson League
- ↳ Jimmy Wynn League
- ↳ Mickey Mantle League
- ↳ Keller Stargell League
- ↳ Joe Jackson League
- ↳ Ty Cobb League
- ↳ Mel Ott League
- ↳ George Van Haltren League
- ↳ Duke Snider League
- ↳ Earl Averill League
- ↳ Jimmy Ryan League
- ↳ Dom DiMaggio League
- ↳ Fred Lynn League
- ↳ Carl Yastrzemski League
- ↳ Reggie Jackson League
- ↳ Ryan Doby League
- ↳ Medwick Jackson League
- ↳ Speed Leagues
- ↳ Don Newcombe League
- ↳ Sandberg Yingling League
- ↳ 24 Team League
- ↳ Ozzie Smith League
- ↳ Gibson Feller League
- ↳ Jumbo Brown League
- ↳ Frank Robinson League
- ↳ Tony Conigliaro League
- ↳ Harmon Killebrew League
- ↳ Wally Berger League
- ↳ Ford Hernandez League
- ↳ Ted Williams League
- ↳ Nomar Garciaparra League
- ↳ Tommy John League
- ↳ Vince Coleman League
- ↳ Amos Otis League
- ↳ Gaylord Perry League
- ↳ Branch Rickey League
- ↳ Bob Horner League
- ↳ Billy Williams League
- ↳ Reggie Smith League
- ↳ Molitor Delahanty League
- ↳ Carlton Fisk League
- ↳ Thurman Munson League
- ↳ Walter Johnson League
- ↳ Paul Waner League
- ↳ Lou Brock League
- ↳ Dale Murphy League
- ↳ Cy Young League
- ↳ Vin Scully League
- ↳ Cool Papa Bell League
- ↳ Jackie Robinson League
- ↳ Vance Bostock Jr League
- ↳ Bill Mazeroski League
- ↳ Jeter Wood League
- ↳ Luis Aparicio League
- ↳ Dave Winfield League
- ↳ Mike Schmidt League
- ↳ Mark Fidrych League
- ↳ Dennis Eckersley League
- ↳ Mike Piazza League
- ↳ Jimmie Foxx League
- ↳ Albert Pujols League
- ↳ Andres Galarraga League
- ↳ Ed ONeill League
- ↳ Jesse Orosco League
- ↳ Murray Maddux League
- ↳ Tony Gwynn League
- ↳ Vida Blue League
- ↳ Orlando Cepeda League
- ↳ Orlando Cepeda League (Majors)
- ↳ Orlando Cepeda League (AAA)
- ↳ Orlando Cepeda League (AA)
- ↳ Dan Quisenberry League
- ↳ Nettles Ruth League
- ↳ Graig Nettles League
- ↳ Babe Ruth League
- ↳ Satchel Paige League
- ↳ Lou Whitaker League
- ↳ Harold Baines League
- ↳ Aaron Fox League
- ↳ Hank Aaron League
- ↳ Nellie Fox League
- ↳ Wilson Roberts League
- ↳ Robin Roberts League
- ↳ Mookie Wilson League
- ↳ Roberto Clemente League
- ↳ Smith Murphy League
- ↳ Rollie Fingers League
- ↳ Ramirez Berra League
- ↳ Jim Edmonds League
- ↳ Bobby Doerr League
- ↳ Santo Rodriguez League
- ↳ Ron Santo League
- ↳ Ivan Rodriguez League
- ↳ Robin Yount League
- ↳ Trial Leagues
- ↳ Ban Johnson League
- ↳ Dave Foutz League
- ↳ Del Baker League
- ↳ Connie Mack League
- ↳ Herman Franks League
- ↳ Les Moss League
- ↳ Clark Griffith League
- ↳ John Clapp League
- ↳ Kid Gleason League
- ↳ Al Lopez League
- ↳ George Sisler League
- ↳ Doc Edwards League
- ↳ Dick Howser League
- ↳ Cito Gaston League
- ↳ Frank Chance League
- ↳ Charlie Finley League
- ↳ Chuck Tanner League
- ↳ Gabby Street League
- ↳ Ossie Vitt League
- ↳ John Hart League
- ↳ Charlie Grimm League
- ↳ Bobby Cox League
- ↳ John Mizerock League
- ↳ Bob Boone League
- ↳ Bobby Bragan League
- ↳ Bruce Bochy League
- ↳ Buck Rodgers League
- ↳ Chick Stahl League
- ↳ Jim Lefebvre League
- ↳ Joe Cantillon League
- ↳ Fred Mitchell League
- ↳ Tommy Lasorda League
- ↳ Joe Cronin League
- ↳ Ned Yost
- ↳ Jack Tighe League
- ↳ Frank Dwyer League
- ↳ Tony LaRussa League
- ↳ Fredi Gonzalez League
- ↳ Heinie Wagner League
- ↳ Terry Bevington League
- ↳ Del Crandall League
- ↳ Darrell Johnson League
- ↳ Lou Piniella League
- ↳ Russ Nixon League
- ↳ George Moriarty League
- ↳ Buck Showalter League
- ↳ Hank Bauer League
- ↳ Johnny Keane League
- ↳ Bill Shettsline League
- ↳ Sam Perlozzo League
- ↳ Shano Collins League
- ↳ Harry Craft League
- ↳ Jim Fregosi League
- ↳ Bucky Harris League
- ↳ Major League Baseball
- ↳ Caimanera
- ↳ Red Viper Baseball League
- ↳ MLB
- ↳ Brett Gardner League
- ↳ Harry Higham
- ↳ Bob Unglaub League
- ↳ Bobby Valentine League
- ↳ Bill Killefer League
- ↳ Billy Hitchcock League
- ↳ George McBride League
- ↳ Malachi Kittridge League
- ↳ Doug Rader League
- ↳ Jos
- ↳ Champions League (Seasons 1-3)
- ↳ Champions League
- ↳ Deez nuts
- ↳ The Big Time League
- ↳ Champions League (seasons 4-6)
- ↳ Johnny Neun League
- ↳ John McNamara League
- ↳ Roger Bresnahan League
- ↳ Art Fletcher League
- ↳ Birdie Tebbetts League
- ↳ Jim Manning League
- ↳ Danny Ozark League
- ↳ Dave Trembley League
- ↳ Eddie Sawyer League
- ↳ George Stovall League
- ↳ Grady Hatton League
- ↳ Harry Walker League
- ↳ Honus Wagner League
- ↳ Horace Phillips League
- ↳ Jack McCallister League
- ↳ Jeff Torborg League
- ↳ John Morrill League
- ↳ Bill Russell League
- ↳ Hod Ford
- ↳ Jim Bottomley League
- ↳ Luis Pujols League
- ↳ Mickey Cochrane League
- ↳ national league
- ↳ Kevin Kennedy League
- ↳ League
- ↳ Red Rolfe League
- ↳ Paul Richards League
- ↳ Phil Regan League
- ↳ Roger Craig League
- ↳ Tony Muser League
- ↳ Larry Parrish League
- ↳ John Russell League
- ↳ Al Buckenberger League
- ↳ Stump Merrill League
- ↳ Bill Watkins League
- ↳ Bob Ferguson League
- ↳ George Huff League
- ↳ Eddie Dyer League
- ↳ Joe Kelley League
- ↳ Ray Miller League
- ↳ Dave Bristol League
- ↳ Sam Mele League
- ↳ Kerby Farrell League
- ↳ Cecil Cooper League
- ↳ Mayo Smith League
- ↳ Frank Bancroft League
- ↳ IBL
- ↳ Lena Blackburne League
- ↳ Mike Ferraro League
- ↳ Walt Alston League
- ↳ Jimmie Wilson League
- ↳ Don Wakamatsu League
- ↳ Prince George Major League
- ↳ Buddy Bell League
- ↳ Salary Leagues
- ↳ Catfish Hunter League
- ↳ Kevin Brown League
- ↳ Barry Zito League
- ↳ Andy Messersmith League
- ↳ Edit Leagues
- ↳ Bill Veeck League
- ↳ Mordecai Brown League
- ↳ Archived Leagues
- ↳ Brett Butler League
- ↳ Johnny Evers League
- ↳ Fergie Jenkins League
- ↳ Sandy Amoros League
- ↳ Phil Niekro League
- ↳ Old Vizquel Spahn League
- ↳ Old Murray Maddux League
- ↳ Temporary Dynasty Holding League
- ↳ Pie Traynor League
- Football League Discussions
- ↳ Premium Leagues
- ↳ Jim Brown Football League
- ↳ Jim Thorpe Football League
- ↳ Curly Lambeau Football League
- ↳ Franco Harris Football League
- ↳ Vince Lombardi Football League
- ↳ Emmitt Smith Football League
- ↳ Marcus Allen Football League
- ↳ Tony Dorsett Football League
- ↳ Barry Sanders Football League
- ↳ Eric Dickerson Football League
- ↳ Walter Payton Football League
- ↳ Gale Sayers Football League
- ↳ Larry Csonka Football League
- ↳ Single Season Leagues
- ↳ Ray Lewis Football League
- ↳ Peyton Manning Football League
- ↳ Kurt Warner Football League
- ↳ Bob Lilly Football League
- ↳ Fran Tarkenton Football League
- ↳ Dan Marino Football League
- ↳ Reggie White Football League
- ↳ Joe Greene Football League
- ↳ Randy Moss Football League
- ↳ Jerry Rice Football League
- ↳ Merlin Olsen Football League
- ↳ Dick Butkus Football League
- ↳ Johnny Unitas Football League
- ↳ Brett Favre Football League
- ↳ Joe Namath Football League
- ↳ single1
- ↳ John Elway Football League
- ↳ Steve Young Football League
- ↳ Junior Seau Football League
- ↳ Jack Youngblood Football League
- ↳ Joe Montana Football League
- ↳ Chris Doleman Football League
- ↳ Zach Thomas Football League
- ↳ Willie Wood Football League
- Baseball Team, Draft and Trade Help
- Football Team, Draft and Trade Help
- Sports Talk
- Off Topic
- Baseball Beta Testing/Development
- Football Beta Testing/Development