Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Moderators: CrazedCougars, The_Old_Bear
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Back to ballots. All participation is appreciated, you know the drill. This is a small one, should be another anytime from soon to a month depending on how lazy I am.
Starters
Ed Benes
Steve Myers
Hiroaki Takeoka
Jay Pettit
Jason Hermansen
Relievers
Glenn Doane
Milt Larkin
As always, thanks in advance to all.
Starters
Ed Benes
Steve Myers
Hiroaki Takeoka
Jay Pettit
Jason Hermansen
Relievers
Glenn Doane
Milt Larkin
As always, thanks in advance to all.
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Given that half the players on this ballot are my own, let it be known that I am extremely biased.
Benes
Hermansen
Doane
Larkin
Benes
Hermansen
Doane
Larkin
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
I like them all, but Takeoka is the least worthy.
-
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 6:49 pm
-
- Posts: 172
- Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2017 9:53 am
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
All ... and yes I did look at them.
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Everyone except Takeoka.
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Just taking a moment to say I plan to vote, but dealing with some health crap that's making it difficult to do anything more than work, commute, and keep my SimD teams afloat ... many roster moves have gone neglected ... but I'm hoping maybe toward the end of the week, if you can wait that long. If not, carry on, pip pip, all that ....
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
Correct!CrazedCougars wrote: ↑Sat May 12, 2018 11:08 pmJust to clarify, is that a vote for all but Takeoka?
Re: Hall of Fame Nominees (2005-2009): Pitchers
No to Jay Pettit. And Steve Myers.
I want to say no to a couple others, but I won't. You just can't deny 300 wins (looking at you, Ed Benes). Yes to everyone else.
But heinerkin, I'm curious ... if you keep Takeoka out, don't you also have to keep Myers (and a couple others) out? With the exception of the Win totals, his Player Card is remarkably similar to Jason Hermanson's card. Are we holding his team environment against him? Asking for a friend...
I want to say no to a couple others, but I won't. You just can't deny 300 wins (looking at you, Ed Benes). Yes to everyone else.
But heinerkin, I'm curious ... if you keep Takeoka out, don't you also have to keep Myers (and a couple others) out? With the exception of the Win totals, his Player Card is remarkably similar to Jason Hermanson's card. Are we holding his team environment against him? Asking for a friend...